Why the Process Matters
The odds without a process are poor.
40%
of executives hired at the senior level were pushed out, failed or quit within 18 months
Source: Kevin Kelly, then CEO of Heidrick & Struggles, on the firm's internal study of 20,000 searches, reported in the Financial Times.
46%
of new hires failed within 18 months, and only 19% achieved unequivocal success
Source: Leadership IQ, "Why New Hires Fail", a study of more than 20,000 new hires.
75%
of the people hired by the largest companies turn out to be a disappointment or worse
According to a survey of Global 100 HR executives reported by Dr. Bradford Smart, author of Topgrading.
Read more on Insights: Why a good interview is not a good hire.
Our Search Process
The Signal Method
Two things have to go right in a search. You have to interview the right talent, and you have to hire them with the right process. We run both.
Our record: 213+ executive searches over the last 12 years. 93% of the people we place are still in the role after 12 months, and 87% after 24 months.
A senior GTM hire is one of the most expensive decisions your company will make. The wrong VP of Sales, Account Executive or Sales Engineer can cost you several quarters of pipeline. Most mis-hires come from the process, not bad luck: gut-feel interviews, claimed accomplishments nobody checks, and a candidate pool limited to people who are already job hunting. This process fixes all three, from the first conversation through your new hire's first year.
Every Search Has Two Parts
Finding the right talent is the first part. Hiring them with the right process is the second.
Here is how we run each one.
Part 1: Finding the Right Talent
1
Our talent network
Every search starts here: a network built over 213+ searches since 2014, with proven performers who don't answer job posts.
2
The whole market, mapped
On engaged and retained searches, our research team maps every company where your next hire could be working today.
3
In the market fast
Retained and engaged searches are in the market within five business days, contingency searches within ten.
4
People worth meeting
Engaged and retained: 3 to 7 qualified finalists, usually in 5 to 10 business days. Contingency: your first candidates, usually in 10 to 20 business days.
Your Market Map covers the companies winning and losing in your space, your direct and indirect competitors, the partner ecosystem, and talent identified in prior searches. For each target, it shows what might push a candidate out of their current company and what would pull them toward yours. Our talent network reaches proven GTM performers who aren't applying to job postings or answering cold recruiter messages, so you meet people your search would otherwise miss. Then we widen the search. Most of the people you want are employed, performing well, and ignoring generic recruiter messages. Referrals from our network conversations widen the pool further. Every candidate you meet comes with an executive summary covering accomplishments, scorecard results, interview findings, and why they would make the move. On retained searches, you also get a market report: who we contacted, how the market responded, compensation expectations, and how your company is perceived. Every search is confidential, for your company and for every candidate.
Part 2: Hiring Them With the Right Process
The right talent is half the hire.
You can interview great talent and still make a hiring mistake. The mistake is made in the process around the candidate: a scorecard nobody agreed on, interviews that reward charm, a record nobody checked.
Fix the whole process and the odds change. Topgrading reports that across 52 of its published case studies, the share of new hires who became top performers rose from 26% to 85%. Two technology companies in Topgrading's case studies reported 90% and 95%.

Same companies. A different process. Better hires. That is the case for the Signal Method: six steps that work as one chain, from the intake call to your new hire's first year.
The Six-Step Signal Method
Every search starts with the intake call, the scorecard and the Truth Serum. Engaged and retained searches run all six steps in full.
1
2
3
4
5
6
Scorecard
Structured Interviews
Truth Serum
Verified Record
Work Sample, Where It Fits
First-Year Review
Skip it and every interviewer hires for a different job.
Skip it and the best interviewer wins.
Skip it and the story goes unchallenged.
Skip it and you hear only what the candidate chose to tell you.
Skip it and you see how they talk, not how they think.
Skip it and nobody learns whether the hire worked.
✓ Every search
✓ Every search
✓ Every search: at least a 90-day check-in
1. Scorecard
We agree what the hire must deliver before anyone is interviewed. Skip it and every interviewer hires for a different job.
We learn the business, not just the job description. We meet with you and the others involved in the hiring decision. We learn your growth targets, GTM motion, product, competitors, culture, and where the gaps are today. Together we agree on the timeline and who makes the decisions, and you get a progress update every week. We build the Performance Profile and Scorecard; define what this hire has to deliver, what will get in the way, and which accomplishments predict success in your environment. That becomes a written scorecard of the leadership, functional and technical skills required, and every candidate is measured against it. Your interview team can use the same scorecard later for your internal assessments. On engaged and retained searches, we build your Employer Value Proposition. Top performers don't leave good jobs for a job description. We work with you to define why proven talent should join you: your mission, the size of the opportunity, the team, and what they can build. That becomes the message for every candidate conversation, and you can reuse it for future hires.
2. Structured Interviews
The same accomplishment questions and the same scale for every candidate. Skip it and the best interviewer wins.
We assess candidates against your scorecard. In our first conversation with every candidate we introduce the Truth Serum described in Step 3: if they reach the final round, they will personally arrange reference calls between your hiring team and the managers they reported to in their most recent roles. In our experience, candidates who cannot stand behind their record usually withdraw at this point, before anyone on your team has spent time with them. Every qualified candidate who continues goes through a structured interview built around accomplishments and evidence of past performance, not personality or charm. For roles like Sales or Presales, we test four areas:
3. Truth Serum
From the first conversation, candidates know they will arrange calls with the managers they reported to. Skip it and the story goes unchallenged.
We add a Truth Serum to the process. Dr. Bradford Smart calls it the simplest, most powerful tool in his method. It costs nothing and takes one sentence. From the very first conversation, every candidate is told: "A final step in this process is that you will personally arrange reference calls between the hiring team and the managers you reported to in your most recent roles." Dr. Bradford Smart, author of Topgrading, built his methodology around this technique and calls it the Threat of Reference Check, or "truth serum." Across 52 published case studies, Topgrading reports that companies using its method, with this step at its core, raised the share of hires who became top performers from 26% to 85% (topgrading.com). The mechanism behind Topgrading is consistent with the academic literature: when candidates know their claims will be checked against the people who were there, inflation drops. A review of research on warnings, with a follow-up experiment, found that telling candidates that faking can be detected, and will have consequences, produced a small drop in inflated scores on selection tests (Dwight & Donovan, Human Performance).
4. Verified Record
Those managers confirm what was achieved, and how. Skip it and you hear only what the candidate chose to tell you.
We then run the reference calls the Truth Serum set up: with the candidate's authorization, we speak with the managers they reported to and with people who worked directly with them, not only the references the candidate picks. Candidate-supplied references tell you what the candidate wants you to hear. Manager references verify the accomplishments you are hiring for. You receive the names, contact details, and highlights from every conversation.
5. Work Sample, Where It Fits
A written 90-day plan for your business. Skip it and you see how they talk, not how they think.
We validate your final-round candidates. If you want one as part of your interview process, candidates in the final round complete a written 90-day plan for your business, so you see how they think before you hire them.
6. First-Year Review
Every search includes a 90-day check-in with you and your new hire. On engaged and retained searches, we stay with you through the first year and help you put structured 90 and 180-day check-ins and a 1-year performance review in place. Skip it and nobody learns whether the hire worked. Every placement carries a replacement guarantee: one year on retained searches, six months on engaged, 90 days on exclusive contingency and 30 days on contingency. Full terms are in your agreement.
And the Close
We structure an offer that gets accepted. Before any offer is extended, we confirm the candidate's expectations and resolve open issues, so there are no surprises. We work with you and HR on the package and secure verbal acceptance before the formal written offer goes out. Education and background verification are available on request. We protect the hire through resignation. Counteroffers are the most common way a closed search falls apart and we coach your new hire through the resignation, prepare them for a counteroffer, and confirm the start date in writing.
Every search includes a 90-day check-in. On engaged and retained searches, we stay with you through the first year.
Offer
Verbal acceptance before the written offer
Resignation
We coach your hire through resignation and the counteroffer
Start date
Confirmed in writing
90 days
Structured check-in
180 days
Structured check-in
1 year
Performance review
Replacement guarantee, from the start date
Retained: 1 year
Engaged: 6 months
Exclusive contingency: 90 days
Contingency: 30 days
Full terms are in your agreement.
What Stays Human
✓ No AI screens, scores, ranks or rejects anyone on your search. The Principal does.
✓ The Principal speaks with every candidate before you see them.
✓ No candidate profile reaches you without the Principal's review. AI can draft. The Principal decides what you read.
✓ Every message that goes to the market, with or without your company's name in it, is written or edited by the Principal.
What AI does
◎ Maps the market
◎ Builds target lists
◎ Studies your company before we talk
AI does research, so our time goes to judgment and conversations. Behind the Principal is a dedicated research team that maps the market and builds your target list.
