top of page

Why a Good Interview Is Not a Good Hire

The gut-feel interview does not just fail to help. It makes the decision worse. Dana, Dawes and Peterson tested this directly. In their study, students interviewed other students and predicted their grades. Those given an unstructured interview on top of the past grades predicted worse than those who had the grades alone. In one condition the interviewee was secretly answering questions at random, and evaluators still formed confident impressions and rated the interview as useful. The authors call this sensemaking: an interviewer can build a convincing story out of almost anything a candidate says, and the story crowds out the evidence. (Dana, Dawes & Peterson, "Belief in the unstructured interview: The persistence of an illusion," Judgment and Decision Making.)

The odds without a process are poor.

40%

of executives hired at the senior level were pushed out, failed or quit within 18 months

 

Source: Kevin Kelly, then CEO of Heidrick & Struggles, on the firm's internal study of 20,000 searches, reported in the Financial Times.

46%

of new hires failed within 18 months, and only 19% achieved unequivocal success

 

Source: Leadership IQ, "Why New Hires Fail", a study of more than 20,000 new hires.

75%

of the people hired by the largest companies turn out to be a disappointment or worse

 

According to a survey of Global 100 HR executives reported by Dr. Bradford Smart, author of Topgrading.

The Signs of a Mis-Hire You Are Missing

Senior GTM talent, in sales, presales and customer success alike, are by selection excellent at running a persuasive conversation. That is the job. In an unstructured interview, the same skills that make them good at the job can make them impossible to evaluate.

A confident, articulate story of a big number hit

WHAT IT OFTEN IS

A team result, a market tailwind, or a number the candidate inherited.

 

WHAT CATCHES IT

A structured interview that walks each role in order.

"Great culture fit"

WHAT IT OFTEN IS

Similarity to the interviewer, or charm.

 

WHAT CATCHES IT

The same scorecard questions and scale for every candidate.

A polished 90-day plan or presentation

WHAT IT SHOWS

Maximal performance: the candidate at their best when evaluated.

 

WHAT TO VERIFY

A multi-year track record of what they personally owned.

A polished departure story for every job change

WHAT IT OFTEN IS

A performance exit, a blown-up relationship, or leaving before results came due.

 

WHAT CATCHES IT

Reference calls with the managers they reported to: the Truth Serum.

Fifteen years of relevant experience

WHAT IT OFTEN IS

Time spent, not capability.

 

WHAT CATCHES IT

Screening on accomplishments against the scorecard, not tenure.

A Confident, Articulate Story of a Big Number Hit

What it often is: A team result, a market tailwind, or a number the candidate inherited.

 

Why the typical process misses it: Nobody asks who set the plan, what the team looked like on day one, or what the boss would say the candidate personally drove.

 

What catches it: A structured interview that walks each role in order: situation inherited, plan, actions, result, and what the manager would say about it.

"Great Culture Fit"

What it often is: Similarity to the interviewer, or charm.

 

Why the typical process misses it: Halo and similar-to-me bias are well-documented interviewer errors (Campion, Palmer & Campion, Personnel Psychology).

 

What catches it: The same scorecard questions and the same scoring scale for every candidate, scored before interviewers compare notes.

A Polished 90-Day Plan or Presentation

What it shows: What a candidate can do at their best when they know they’re being evaluated. Researchers call this maximal performance.

​

What the interview can miss: How the candidate makes decisions, handles setbacks, and follows through week after week. Sackett, Zedeck, and Fogli distinguish this typical performance from maximal performance in the Journal of Applied Psychology.

​

What to verify: Pair the work sample with a multi-year track record. Verify what the candidate personally owned, what results they delivered, and whether they did it consistently.

A Polished Departure Story for Every Job Change

What it often is: A performance exit, a blown-up relationship with a manager, or a pattern of leaving just before results came due.

 

Why the typical process misses it: References are picked by the candidate, so the people who saw the exit are never called.

 

What catches it: Reference calls with the managers the candidate reported to, arranged by the candidate, which is the Truth Serum.

Fifteen Years of Relevant Experience

What it often is: Time spent, not capability.

 

Why the typical process misses it: The resume screen is the first filter and it weights the weakest signal most heavily.

 

What catches it: Screening on accomplishments against the scorecard, not tenure.

What Happens When the Whole Process Changes

Topgrading reports that across 52 published case studies, companies using its method raised the share of hires who became top performers from 26% to 85%. Mint.com reported that 90% of the people it hired became top performers. Virtual Technology reported 19 of 20. A doctoral study at Georgia State University looked at six companies using the method: mis-hire rates reported by the companies' own leaders fell from 69.3% to 10.5%.

 

No study isolates how much any one step contributes. That is the case for using the steps together: a scorecard, structured interviews, the Truth Serum, verified references, a work sample where it fits, and a review of the hire against the scorecard in the first year.

Sources

1. Dana, J., Dawes, R., & Peterson, N. Belief in the unstructured interview: The persistence of an illusion. Judgment and Decision Making, 8(5), 512-520. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1930297500003612

2. Campion, M. A., Palmer, D. K., & Campion, J. E. A review of structure in the selection interview. Personnel Psychology, 50(3), 655-702.

3. Sackett, P. R., Zedeck, S., & Fogli, L. Relations between measures of typical and maximum job performance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 73(3), 482-486.

4. Huffcutt, A. I., & Arthur, W. Hunter and Hunter (1984) revisited: Interview validity for entry-level jobs. Journal of Applied Psychology, 79(2), 184-190. Cited for the finding that interview validity rises with structure.

5. Dwight, S. A., & Donovan, J. J. Do warnings not to fake reduce faking? Human Performance, 16(1), 1-23.

6. Smart, B. D. Topgrading, 3rd Edition: The Proven Hiring and Promoting Method That Turbocharges Company Performance. Portfolio/Penguin. Threat of Reference Check (TORC) technique. See also Topgrading blog, "The Topgrading Truth Serum Never Fails" and "Powerful Reference Check Method Gets Even Better," blog.topgrading.com.

7. Topgrading. Case study results across 52 published case studies, and the Mint.com and Virtual Technology case studies. topgrading.com

8. Lorence, M. S. The Impact of Systematically Hiring Top Talent: A Study of Topgrading as a Rigorous Employee Selection Bundle. Doctoral dissertation, Georgia State University.

bottom of page