top of page
Search

The VP of Sales Trap: Why Good Intentions Aren’t Enough

Writer: Steven Shaffer
Steven Shaffer
7 days ago
3 min read

Why 70% of First VP of Sales Hires Go Wrong




Let’s be honest, no founder wakes up thinking, “Today, I’ll make a disastrous executive hire.” Yet, somehow, when it comes to bringing on that first VP of Sales, startups keep tripping over the same wire. It’s almost like watching a slow motion car crash: you see it coming, you want to look away, but you just can’t.


Why does this happen? Well, the pressure is real. There’s the relentless drumbeat to “own revenue,” the bone-deep exhaustion from carrying the sales torch yourself, and, of course, the board’s not-so-subtle nudges. It’s a cocktail that makes rash decisions feel almost reasonable. But here’s the thing, this mindset is exactly what sets the stage for trouble.


Fixing vs. Scaling: The Olympic Swimmer in an Empty Pool


Here’s a question: Are you hiring a VP of Sales to fix your sales, or to scale it? It sounds like splitting hairs, but it’s the difference between building a house and just painting the walls.


A lot of founders, worn out and desperate for relief, see the VP of Sales as a magic bullet. Sales aren’t working? Bring in the pro! But if you’re still figuring out who your buyer is, what your sales motion looks like, or how to price your product, you’re not ready for a VP of Sales. You’re still searching for product–founder fit, not VP of Sales fit.


Picture this: You hire an Olympic swimmer, point at an empty pool, and say, “Win me a gold medal.” Sounds ridiculous, right? That’s what it’s like to bring in a VP of Sales before you’ve nailed the basics. They’re built to accelerate a proven process, not invent it from scratch. If you’re still experimenting, you’re asking them to do your job. And that’s a recipe for disappointment.


The Resume Mirage: When Big Logos Blind You


Now, let’s talk about the siren song of the resume. It’s tempting, almost irresistible, to be dazzled by candidates who’ve worked at the big names. That ex BigCo VP? They’ve led armies of sales reps, managed eye-watering quotas, and probably have a LinkedIn profile that reads like a Fortune 500 highlight reel.


But here’s the catch: Have they ever built the first three sales hires from scratch? Or did they just inherit a well-oiled machine? On paper, they’re perfect. In practice, they might expect a small army of SDRs, a RevOps team, and a brand that opens doors for them. Your startup? You’ve got…well, you.


If a candidate hasn’t taken a company from your stage to the next, they’re more of a risk than an asset. It’s like hiring a Michelin-star chef to cook in a tent with a camp stove. Sure, they know their stuff, but can they handle the chaos, the lack of resources, the need to improvise? Sometimes, grit and adaptability matter more than a shiny pedigree.


So, When Are You Actually Ready for a VP of Sales?


Alright, so if hiring too soon is a trap, when’s the right time? Here’s what you should look for:


  • You’ve got a repeatable, founder led sales process. You know what works, and you can teach it.

  • You’re clear on your ideal customer profile (ICP) and buyer. No more guessing games.

  • Losing deals hurts more because you can’t handle the volume, not because you’re confused. You’re losing out because you’re stretched thin, not because you’re lost.


That’s the sweet spot. When you’ve built a foundation, a VP of Sales can come in and pour fuel on the fire. Bring them in too early, and you’re just handing them a box of matches and hoping for the best.


Avoiding the Slow-Motion Car Crash


So, what’s the takeaway? Don’t let exhaustion or pressure push you into a hasty hire. Resist the urge to be wowed by big company resumes if they don’t fit your stage. And most importantly, wait until you’ve got the basics down: your process, your buyer, your product’s place in the world.


Honestly, it’s tough. The temptation to hand off sales is strong, especially when you’re running on fumes. But a little patience now can save you a world of pain later. Take a breath, build your foundation, and when the time’s right, you’ll know. Your future VP of Sales, and your board, will thank you.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page